Who is Accountable? | Certification: Mitigating the Risk – Part 6

From CEO to administrative assistant:  Where does accountability lie?

We have worked in the charitable sector since 1986, first building systems and, since 1993, delivering our application @EASE to the broader charitable market. Helping organizations build the dollars they need for the programs and services they provide has been, and still is, a wonderful opportunity.

During this time, we have interacted with numerous executive directors, fund development staff, volunteers, administrative staff, and Board members.

The results have been interesting and sometimes concerning, as some folks are navigating an area they are unfamiliar with. It is not that they are not nice people who want to do a good job; it is simply that they may not fully understand the scope of the job and, in many cases, lack the skills and understanding of what is truly required.

It recalls the Dunning-Kruger effect, a cognitive bias in which people may lack the skills or knowledge but treat fundraising and charity management like a business and overestimate their own competencies in the process.

I believe accountability starts at the top of an organization. It demands that leaders ensure jobs are filled based on competencies.

Take the job of the fund development manager. Yes, they can ask for donations, but literally anyone can ask for money. This important role involves so much more, especially when it comes to managing campaigns and donors. If these individuals lack the necessary skill set, training is essential to their personal success and the charity’s success. Often, “guessing” becomes a strategy.

We have been told that staff training is too costly. What is the alternative?  Pay staff to undermine data integrity and ignore relationship management, a key to the charity’s sustainability?

Then we have the Board. Lots of folks enjoy being on a Board, but again, there is so much more to the role than adding it to a resume. It means commitment. It means attending events and inviting friends to meet the charity. It means attending Board meetings and coming prepared. It means being entrepreneurial and not being afraid to try something new. It means being proud of the charity you support and advocating for it.

Story One: We had a lovely hospital foundation that was running a capital campaign. Interestingly, rather than approaching the broader community they served, the Board chose to focus only on In Memory donations. That is not a capital campaign.

Story Two: A client with lovely staff was poised to run a 200K campaign for new equipment. This foundation had never made more than 50K in any one year, not because they could not bring in more charitable dollars, but because their Board only supported one small campaign a year. If you are not advocating for your organization by letting the community know its value and asking for their participation, your efforts are inadequate.

Story Three: We had a client who went through several staff changes over a few weeks, to the point that we offered to manage their campaigns to keep them functioning. Unfortunately, their inaction corrupted their data. This was simply the result of too many untrained people trying to do a task they weren’t qualified to do, and the outcome was disastrous.

While there can be many factors, in our opinion, problems can start at the most senior level if there is little planning, little knowledge, and no documentation of what each role in the organization involves.

As we have addressed in our previous articles, there are key areas where new hires and particularly senior management or new Board members, require training and knowledge about the charity and how it functions.

The most senior person in a group does not need to know every detail, but they do need to know what employees in various roles are expected to do. By hiring skilled, knowledgeable people to manage individual areas, assurances of that knowledge, or its absence, funnel back to the top.  This is true accountability.

It is much more than a title at whatever level a person holds in an organization. It is understanding the gravity and requirements of direct reports. It means ensuring your staff members can do their job correctly and on time.

When things go awry … accountability surges up the staff pipeline to the very top.

Certification establishes the elements a charity needs to be sustainable and operate to maintain donor confidence.

(This is the last of a series of six articles on this topic.)

Sharron Batsch is the developer of @EASE Fund Development Software and the author of From Chaos to Control, Build a High Performance Team Using Knowledge Management. She has worked with a wide variety of charities for over 36 years as both a consultant and volunteer fundraiser and event chair. She developed and managed a training program through Continuing Education for the University of Manitoba for the business use of microcomputer solutions offering 147 courses annually. While at the University she redeveloped a certificate program in Information Management and hosted a breakfast series for senior IT managers. She has received awards for her work in Knowledge Management from the Consulting Engineers of Canada and the Alberta Consulting Engineers. Her work helps define how charities can best use the data they collect and create an environment with 15 second retrieval using a Knowledge Management System. She specializes in information management for the not-for-profit community.

Sharron Batsch
Sharron Batsch